Season 2
(2023)
Cast
as Self - Host
Episodes
Ben died. Do we feel bad about that? 7.0
August 8, 2023
Ben’s not the nicest, but was this overkill? We share our take on Ben Glenroy with host Michael Cyril Creighton, Jackie…
Should Mabel be investigating right now? 8.0
August 8, 2023
Who needs a job when you have a murder podcast? We explore Mabel’s life choices on One Killer Question, the Only Murder…
Does T-obert stand for Trouble? 6.0
August 15, 2023
Mabel made a new friend. Does Tobert spell trouble? Join host Michael Cyril Creighon, Jason Veasey (Jonathon) and Don D…
What Happened in the White Room? 6.0
August 22, 2023
What the heck happened in the white room. And why are pants involved? Andrea Martin (Joy) and Kara Wang join host Micha…
Is Our Trio in Love With Murder? 6.0
August 29, 2023
Dating is tricky when your real passion is murder. We break down the trio’s love lives with Jay Manuel, Sophia Culpo, J…
Who’s the most haunted? 0.0
September 5, 2023
Do you believe in ghosts? Because in this episode everyone’s haunted. Let’s get exorcising with host Michael Cyril Crei…
Who does Mabel belong with? 0.0
September 12, 2023
Theo keeps popping up in Mabel’s life. Is it a sign? James Caverly (Theo) shares his unbiased take with Ryan Broussard …
Is Oliver’s Heart Messing With His Head? 4.0
September 19, 2023
Oliver’s always been self-obsessed. But this season he’s been flat out selfish. Join Andrea Martin (Joy), Ryan Broussar…
We Were Kinda Unfair to Ben? 7.0
September 26, 2023
Ben didn’t make a great first impression. But was he such a bad guy? We reevaluate this season’s victim with Jeremy Sha…
For the Sake of a Child? 0.0
October 3, 2023